Muslims Should Read/ Study the Bible: OKAY!


Muslims should read the Bible? Is this truly the best way to convert someone to Christianity? I’d like to thank the missionaries who spend thousands of dollars on printing Bibles and giving them to starving children to save them from hunger. Reading a Bible converts no one, I bought my own first copy because no one would give me one, if reading the Bible actually convinces anyone of anything, it would be to recognize its flaws and to search for the true faith at which it hosts many indications of. Let’s take a basic example in which an idiot savant (read as: Sam “tha thug” Shamoun) would be able to notice these basic flaws. We begin with the birth narrative in Matthew 2, versus that of Luke 2.

Matthew 2:

  • Joseph and Mary live in Bethlehem (2:1).
  • Joseph, Mary and baby God/ Jesus migrate to Egypt  for fear of their safety (2:12).
  • Joseph, Mary and baby God/ Jesus do not go to Jerusalem to fulfill the birth rite law of of the Old Testament (Luke 2:23).

Luke 2:

  • Joseph and Mary live in Galilee but travel to Bethlehem to pay taxes because the entire Roman world was being taxed. Problem, why would they move to a town that Joseph is originally from to be taxed, wouldn’t the tax collector want to collect the taxes from people in their respective cities/ towns (2:1)?
  • No account of Joseph, Mary and baby God/ Jesus migrating to Egypt for fear of safety – rather they stay in Bethlehem for 8 days and wait for Mary to become pure again after giving birth (2:20-21).
  • Joseph, Mary and baby God/ Jesus do go to Jerusalem to fulfill the birth rite law of of the Old Testament (Luke 2:22-23).

At first, it might not seem like a big deal, but as Rabbi Michael Skobac of Jews for Judaism pointed out in his video on Micah 5:1-3, the stories claim opposite narratives which cannot be reconciled. In one episode of pure fiction, Mary and Joseph and baby God/ Jesus is scared of being persecuted by the Roman authorities and they flee, and even upon returning to the land of Israel they remain in hiding due to danger. In Luke, the story is quite different, they stay in Bethlehem, wait for Mary to become pure – absolutely no hiding or fear of danger, they stay a little more than a month, then journey to Jerusalem and present Christ at the temple – again no fear of danger, no hiding – nothing.

cc-2013-bibleMakesNoSense

Now that I’ve read the Bible, I’m more convinced not to be a Christian. Muslims should therefore read the Bible. Saudi Arabia should allow the Bible to be taught and it should be mandatory for every child to be able to explain these differences. Perhaps in that way, the rest of the remaining Christians in the Middle East can finally abandon the chains of the cross and come to true monotheism – God willing.

8 comments

  • The events of Joseph, Mary and Jesus going to Egypt happen when Jesus is two years old as Matthew says. Luke’s account is before this time.

  • Hi Samuel, I suppose Matthew 2:16 is what you’re referring to. How does that solve the issue of danger and fear, by way of running and hiding?

  • not sure I agree with statements like:

    ‘if reading the Bible actually convinces anyone of anything, it would be to leave/ abandon Christianity’

    ‘This book makes no damed sense’

    Despite the Bible’s well known difficulties, as a Christian I learnt many truths about God, morality and the teaching of the prophets of God, which changed my life – for the better.

    Much of the Bible makes a great deal of sense to me even today as a Muslim: the beautiful parables of Jesus; the gloriously monotheistic preaching of Isaiah; the Book of Jonah; Proverbs; the Psalms; the Sermon on the Mount etc.

    Perhaps a more nuanced appreciation of the pros and cons?

  • what were the christians saying about consistency in oral traditions? lol

    hilery clinton, matthew and luke all in the same boat

  • could Ijaz Ahmad perhaps give a more balanced appraisal of the Bible in an article?

  • Duly noted Br. Paul, no doubt there are many things I myself have learned due to the Bible. This article however is not to discuss the pros and cons of the Bible, it’s about demonstrating to the missionaries who hand out Bibles that it’s not going to ‘convert’ us, we read it and we understand its errors, we already have true guidance.

    Thanks for your comments though, Allaahu ‘Alam.

  • InshaaAllaah Br. Paul, see the edited post.

  • Hi Ijaz
    Mat 2:22    But when he heard that Archelaus did reign in Judaea in the room of his father Herod, he was afraid to go thither: notwithstanding, being warned of God in a dream, he turned aside into the parts of Galilee:Mat 2:23    And he came and dwelt in a city called Nazareth: that it might be fulfilled which was spoken by the prophets, He shall be called a Nazarene.

    If you know anything about Archelaus you would understand why Joseph didnt go back there, this man was a wicked man probably worse than his dad.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s