Response to ‘James White says what again?’


Bismillahir Rahmanir Raheem
بِسۡمِ ٱللهِ ٱلرَّحۡمَـٰنِ ٱلرَّحِيمِ ,

James White has released another video, completely missing the mark on our previous video, while misleading his viewership. Note, we released this 40 minute video as a response to, “MuslimByChoice refuted en toto”:

Unfortunately, James decided he didn’t want to respond to the 40 minute video, apparently it was easier to reference a subclip from a 1 minute video based on the 40 minute response we did to him. In this regard, here is our latest response to James White:

I hope that James can hold himself to the same standards that he holds us, it was quite disappointing to see him defrauding his viewership by misleading them with a 1 minute video, whereas purposely neglecting or rather ignoring it’s predecessor under which it was based upon.

wa Allaahu Alam.
[and God knows best].

17 comments

  • Defrauding? Really?

    I don’t think you have a leg to stand on when you accuse Dr. White this way.

    How about you call into his program and that way you’d be able to dialogue in “real time”

    But I don’t think you have that kind of courage…I think you’d rather accuse and run….prove me wrong.

    1-877-753-3341 is the call-in number to the Dividing Line.

  • Hi there!
    I tried adding the Dividing Line via Skype as this is most accessible to me, however Richard has as of yet not accepted my request. I am willing to call in and speak with James live, this isn’t a problem.

    Thanks for your advice, it is well noted.

  • Fair enough.
    I emailed Rich and told him that you were having trouble and would like to talk to Dr. White on his show…that might help (though if you really wanted to you could have done the same) 🙂

  • I had a discussion with A. Santana and I has asked him, since he knew them to pass on my message to them, thought it would be quicker.

  • Ijaz Ahmad,
    Rich just told me that you don’t have to be “accepted” to get through, all you have to do is call in during the time the DL is on.

    The ball seems to be in your court now…what are you going to do with it?

  • This Tuesday, I’ll call in, have some fun.

  • Ijaz Ahmad….that sounds great…I’ll let Rich and Dr. White know.

    I’ll be sure to listen.

  • Sorry to drag this out but Rich said make sure you listen to the show so you know that they are taking calls that day….don’t give up! 🙂

  • I usually listen to the show when they stream live on Tuesday and sometimes Thursdays.

  • that’s great to hear…I’d be interested in how this plays out considering you both seem to be on different pages as far as what reality is in this situation….

    Please do me a favor….listen to his arguments and give them consideration…don’t stoop to the (sometimes) usual lame-o Islamic arguments.

    Hear what he’s saying and respond to it….ok?

  • I do listen to his arguments, and then I break them down, then respond directly to them. Never not responded directly to his arguments, before you watch his videos, watch *mines* first, so you’d see what I’m saying and then see what he represents me as saying.

  • Well…to be perfectly honest….that’s why I mentioned it… 🙂

  • I didn’t catch your call on the Dividing like….did you call or was that all bluster above?

  • Sorry, unavailable for apologetics work until after the 18th of this month of May. I had to also move two debates two the latter end of the month was well.

  • Unavailable?

    A 15 minute phone call?

    Dr. White does his show on the road from hotel rooms all over the world….and you can’t squeeze in 15 minutes after all this bluster and posturing?

    We have our answer…too bad you couldn’t do more than shoot from behind the keyboard…that would have been instructive to hear.

  • It is very unlikely the Skype call will last 15 minutes, as the RC call took almost an entire hour.

    I have to contend with the variation in time zones, I’m a few hours ahead, and I’m usually busy in the evenings. I don’t have to justify my reasons for not calling until the 18th. Post the 18th check me, otherwise keep your spurious statements to yourself, thanks.