If Allah is so powerful, why can’t He become a man?


At first glance, this seems like a pretty strong argument. God in both Christianity and Islam is defined to be all powerful. So if God is all powerful, why does Christianity say He can become a man and Islam say He cannot? The Christian’s argument does not include a deep study on the nature of God and due to this, it is very simple to debunk this argument.

Defining God

Both Muslims and Christians believe that God is an all powerful being.

God’s Nature is Absolute

Both Muslims and Christians believe that God’s nature does not change, He was all powerful, is all powerful and will always be all powerful.

Man’s Nature Differs 

Both Muslims and Christians believe that mankind is not all powerful.

Muslim Response

If God is all powerful and man is not all powerful, can God’s nature of being all powerful, change to becoming not all powerful? How can an all powerful God become less powerful?

Conclusion

  • God is all powerful.
  • If God gains power, then by definition He was not all powerful before and thus cannot be considered a God.
  • If God loses power, then by definition He is not all powerful and thus cannot be considered a God.

Since a Christian believes that a God can become a man, and a man is not all powerful, how can God remain all powerful yet be unable to defend himself (Christ was allegedly subject to Roman torture) and unable to eat (so hungry he cursed a fig tree)? If God is all powerful, no being should be able to overcome him, since Christ was overcome, then he clearly was not a God. So the simple answer is: Whereas God is always all powerful, man is not.

A Christian apologist may argue Jesus ‘chose’ to take all of these things unto himself, that would still not change the fact that he chose to take on an attribute of weakness by becoming a man, thus meaning he cannot be God because God is always all powerful, and does not change. So by no longer being all powerful, he is no longer God, and the very fact he changed and took on a new nature, when God does not change and always is, also again means he can’t be God.

and Allaah knows best.

3 comments

  • for an omni everthing diety to take on finite attributes makes sense?

    Gods essential attributes are all powerful and all knowing. these must be PART of him /his essense in order for him to do ACTION verbs like mercy, love etc

    this is my understanding.

    now lets see what trinitarians say

    they say that God BECAME man

    does this mean that GOD reWIRED his OWN essense FROM within his body/his SELF /his essense?

    EITHER GOD REVERSEd something with in himself AND MADE it eternally pART of himself before he incarnated or god DID NOT make it from WITHIN himself , but OUT OF himself, his essense, his nature.

    if god MADE hunger, thirst, FATIGUE, LEARNING, ignorance OUT OF himself, then he didn’t experience what it is to be HUMAN

    if god MADE within himself, hunger, thirst, fatigue, learning, ignorance… then god CANCELLED out the word “all” in “all knowing” and “all powerful”

    if god temporary detached himself from his omni powers , then why can’t he HAND THEM over to someone else? how can a God be a God if HE turns off essential attributes like all knowing and power?

    if all KNOWING ATTRIBUTE CAN RUN ON ITS OWN, THEN:

    this would mean that gods attributes like all knowing ARE INDEPENDANT of him and CONTINUE TO RECORD the EVENTS of the world and then later INFORM god on this THINGS he missed out on.

  • Pingback: If Allah is so powerful, why can’t He become a man? | Calling Christians | My Blog

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s